storm-control unicast only for UNKNOWN UNICAST.

Hi lizhuzhu

I tested it with my S5700-10P-LI-AC, only the switch, L2, no router or something else inbetween.

I set storm-control unicast min-rate 500 max-rate 1500 on the switch ports between a client and a server, both running windows.

And it seems the unicast setting has an effect on KNOWN unicast packets, because after 1-2sec the filetransfer (via SMB) stops and the ports get blocked by storm-control!

Strange. And I see no splatter on the other ports in the same VLAN which should happen if it was unkown unicast...

OK, so now I tested s5700-10p-li-v200r008c00spc500

INT Client GE0/0/1 and Server GE0/0/2 look like this (both are in VLAN1):

interface GigabitEthernet0/0/1
port link-type access
stp edged-port enable
port link-flap protection enable
storm-control unicast min-rate 500 max-rate 1500
storm-control action error-down
storm-control enable log

As soon as I start a file copy (ISO-file) storm-control kicks in and kills both ports, it logs everything.

I have connected WIRESHARK to GE0/0/7 to a passive NIC, just to see what happens. I see some (only 4-5) SMB-Packets that get splattered on GE0/0/7, they should not be there. Seems to happen shortly AFTER storm-control kicks in. But as I said: 4-5 packets, nothing big.

I am really wondering...the nics btw. are Intel Pro 1000 CT, so not the worst NICs I think...

OK, here it is. Everything seems ok...but it does not work. Behaves like it blocks UNICAST in general.

<SWITCH>system
Enter system view, return user view with Ctrl+Z.
[SWITCH]display mac-address
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC Address    VLAN/VSI                          Learned-From        Type
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0015-1736-4074 1/-                               GE0/0/1             dynamic
001b-214d-d69c 1/-                               GE0/0/2             dynamic
04bd-70c4-0a2b 99/-                              GE0/0/9             dynamic

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total items displayed = 3

[SWITCH]display arp
IP ADDRESS      MAC ADDRESS     EXPIRE(M) TYPE INTERFACE      VPN-INSTANCE
                                          VLAN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
169.254.1.10    04bd-70c4-09f0            I -  Vlanif1
169.254.163.220 0015-1736-4074  9         D-0  GE0/0/1
                                          1
169.254.50.246  001b-214d-d69c  9         D-0  GE0/0/2
                                          1
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total:3         Dynamic:2       Static:0     Interface:1
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:46+01:00 SWITCH %%01ERRDOWN/4/ERRDOWN_DOWNNOTIFY(l)[0]:Notify interface to change status to error-down. (InterfaceName=GigabitEthernet0/0/2, Cause=storm-control)
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:46+01:00 SWITCH %%01SECE/4/STORMCTRL_IF_ERROR_DOWN(l)[1]:Interface GigabitEthernet0/0/2 is error-down for storm-control.
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:46+01:00 SWITCH %%01IFPDT/4/IF_STATE(l)[2]:Interface GigabitEthernet0/0/2 has turned into DOWN state.
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:46+01:00 SWITCH ERRDOWN/4/ErrordownOccur:OID 1.3.6.1.4.1.2011.5.25.257.2.1 Error-down occured. (Ifindex=6, Ifname=GigabitEthernet0/0/2, Cause=storm-control)
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:49+01:00 SWITCH %%01ERRDOWN/4/ERRDOWN_DOWNNOTIFY(l)[3]:Notify interface to change status to error-down. (InterfaceName=GigabitEthernet0/0/1, Cause=storm-control)
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:49+01:00 SWITCH %%01SECE/4/STORMCTRL_IF_ERROR_DOWN(l)[4]:Interface GigabitEthernet0/0/1 is error-down for storm-control.
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:49+01:00 SWITCH %%01IFPDT/4/IF_STATE(l)[5]:Interface GigabitEthernet0/0/1 has turned into DOWN state.
[SWITCH]
Oct 18 2008 23:13:49+01:00 SWITCH ERRDOWN/4/ErrordownOccur:OID 1.3.6.1.4.1.2011.5.25.257.2.1 Error-down occured. (Ifindex=5, Ifname=GigabitEthernet0/0/1, Cause=storm-control)
[SWITCH]

[SWITCH-GigabitEthernet0/0/1]display this include-default
#
interface GigabitEthernet0/0/1
negotiation auto
auto speed 10 100 1000
auto duplex half full
undo energy-efficient-ethernet enable
mdi auto
undo flow-control negotiation
undo flow-control
undo port-auto-sleep enable
undo loopback
description Kassen-PC
undo shutdown
enable snmp trap updown
undo set flow-stat interval
undo arp detect-mode unicast
arp-fake expire-time 3
port link-type access
undo port vlan-mapping ingress
undo vcmp disable
undo mac-address learning disable
port priority 0
port default vlan 1
qinq protocol 8100
undo port negotiation disable
undo loopback-detect enable
stp enable
undo stp config-digest-snoop
undo stp no-agreement-check
undo stp root-protection
undo stp loop-protection
stp edged-port enable
stp point-to-point auto
stp compliance auto
stp instance 0 port priority 128
undo mac-vlan enable
undo ip-subnet-vlan enable
undo arp validate source-mac destination-mac
undo rmon-statistics
undo smart-link flush receive
stp vlan 1 to 4094 port priority 128
undo mac-forced-forwarding network-port
ntdp enable
ndp enable
bpdu enable
undo portal local-server anonymous
undo portal local-server enable
undo dot1x mac-bypass mac-auth-first
undo dot1x enable
dot1x max-user 1024
dot1x port-control auto
dot1x port-method mac
undo dot1x unicast-trigger
undo dot1x reauthenticate
undo authentication critical eapol-success
authentication max-reauth-req 20
undo mac-authen
mac-authen max-user 1024
mac-authen reauthenticate
undo authentication open
lldp enable
lldp dot3-tlv power 802.1ab
lldp tlv-enable basic-tlv all
lldp tlv-enable dot1-tlv protocol-vlan-id
lldp tlv-enable dot1-tlv port-vlan-id
lldp tlv-enable dot1-tlv vlan-name
undo lldp tlv-enable dot1-tlv protocol-identity
lldp tlv-enable med-tlv network-policy voice-vlan 8021p cos 5 dscp 46
undo lldp tlv-enable med-tlv location-id
lldp tlv-enable med-tlv all
lldp tlv-enable dot3-tlv all
undo lldp compliance cdp txrx
undo lldp compliance cdp receive
sflow counter-sampling interval 10
sflow flow-sampling inbound
sflow flow-sampling outbound
sflow flow-sampling rate 2048
sflow flow-sampling max-header 128
undo port-security enable
undo port bridge enable
undo port-isolate enable
undo ip error-packet-check disable
undo port discard tagged-packet
mac-address flapping action priority 127
undo mac-address flapping action error-down
undo mac-address flapping action quit-vlan
undo mac-address trap notification
jumboframe enable 9216
set flow-statistics include-interframe
trap-threshold input-rate 80 resume-rate 80
trap-threshold output-rate 80 resume-rate 80
log-threshold input-rate 80 resume-rate 80
log-threshold output-rate 80 resume-rate 80
trap-threshold error-statistics 3 interval 10
undo error-statistics threshold-event trigger error-down
undo log-threshold input-discard
undo log-threshold output-discard
carrier up-hold-time 2000
carrier down-hold-time 0
port link-flap protection enable
port link-flap interval 10
port link-flap threshold 5
undo arp anti-attack rate-limit enable
undo arp anti-attack check user-bind enable
undo ip source check user-bind enable
undo user-bind ip sticky-mac
storm-control unicast min-rate 500 max-rate 1500
storm-control interval 5
storm-control action error-down
storm-control enable log
undo broadcast-suppression block outbound
undo multicast-suppression block outbound
undo unicast-suppression block outbound
#

I really don't know what goes wrong here...

I can answer this question now. Read side 226 from the S-Series Configuration Guide - Security for V200R007

Step 3 Run:
storm-control { broadcast | multicast | unicast } min-rate min-rate-value max-rate
max-rate-value
or
storm-control { broadcast | multicast | unicast } min-rate cir min-rate-value-cir
max-rate cir max-rate-value-cir
or
storm-control { broadcast | multicast | unicast } min-rate percent min-rate-valuepercent
max-rate percent max-rate-value-percent
Storm control is performed on broadcast packets, multicast packets, or unknown unicast packets
on the interface.

NOTE
After the
storm-control unicast min-rate min-rate-value max-rate max-rate-value,
storm-control unicast min-rate cir min-rate-value-cir max-rate cir max-rate-value-cir
or storm-control unicast min-rate percent min-rate-value-percent max-rate percent max-rate-value-percent command is executed,
the device suppresses both unknown and known unicast packets.

Somehow, this is very unclear...