QinQ between Huawei and Extreme Networks

chenhui · Created Aug 21, 2019 03:20:37

@welisson_br hello,
For V200R010 and later versions, command qinq protocol can be configured on the Eth-Trunk but not Eth-Trunk member interfaces. Please configure this command on the eth-trunk interface rather the memmer interface.

chenhui · Created Aug 21, 2019 03:20:37

@welisson_br hello,
For V200R010 and later versions, command qinq protocol can be configured on the Eth-Trunk but not Eth-Trunk member interfaces. Please configure this command on the eth-trunk interface rather the memmer interface.

welisson_br · Created Aug 21, 2019 14:30:31

Posted by chenhui at 2019-08-20 16:20@welisson_br hello,For V200R010 and later versions, command qinq protocol can be configured on the E ...

@chenhui hello,

I did that configurations and even have done it, the comunications went down.

We can't have any comunications with the other switch through the vlans tags(l2 or L3) and the qinq didn't work as well.

Cheers

user_2844477 · Created Aug 21, 2019 20:03:02

Hi.
Please post all related cofigurations from Extreme side.

I've done this before, just changed VMAN ethertype to 0x8100 on Extreme side. No changes on Huawei.

welisson_br · Created Aug 22, 2019 02:20:00

Posted by user_2844477 at 2019-08-21 09:03Hi.Please post all related cofigurations from Extreme side. I've done this before, just changed VMAN ...

Hi,

Here it is from Extreme Side.
P.S: the port 29 is 10g as a trunk and forward other vlans including layer 3 vlan, where it is connected with S5720 as I posted above.

show configuration detail | grep vman
configure vman ethertype 0x88a8 or move on to 0x8100 like Huawei, the behavior is the same.
create vman "OLTS"
configure vman OLTS tag 4000
enable flooding vman OLTS
enable learning vman OLTS
configure vman "OLTS" qosprofile none
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 1
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 2
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 3
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 4
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 5
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 6
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 7
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 8
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 9
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 10
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 11
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 12
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 13
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 14
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 15
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 16
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 17
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 18
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 19
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 20
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 21
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 22
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 23
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 24
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 25
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 26
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 27
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 28
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 29
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 30
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 31
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 32
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 33
disable vman cep egress filtering ports 34
configure vman OLTS add ports 29 tagged
configure vman OLTS add ports 1,3-9,11-15,17-18,21,23,25,28 untagged

chenhui · Created Aug 22, 2019 08:24:10

Posted by welisson_br at 2019-08-21 14:30 Posted by chenhui at 2019-08-21 14:30@welisson_br hello,For V200R010 and later versions, command qinq ...

hi,
did you connect the Extreme X460 to S5720 through interface eth-trunk 0?
if yes, you should adjust your configuration as below:

interface GigabitEthernet0/0/11

description CLIENTE_A

qinq protocol 88a8 // delete this command if client A doesn't support 0x88a8

port link-type hybrid

qinq vlan-translation enable

undo port hybrid vlan 1

port hybrid tagged vlan 175

port hybrid untagged vlan 4000

port vlan-stacking vlan 700 stack-vlan 4000

port vlan-stacking vlan 1000 to 1300 stack-vlan 4000

port vlan-stacking vlan 3550 stack-vlan 4000

interface Eth-Trunk0

description TRUNK-SW_EXTREME-20GB

port link-type trunk

undo port trunk allow-pass vlan 1

port trunk allow-pass vlan 175 3011 3218 4000 4076

mode lacp

qinq protocol 88a8 // add this command, so that the frame type of the packets sent to Extreme X460 is 0x88a8

welisson_br · Created Aug 22, 2019 12:54:25

Posted by chenhui at 2019-08-21 21:24hi,did you connect the Extreme X460 to S5720 through interface eth-trunk 0?if yes, you should adju ...

Hi,

I did that, but the result was the same.

Everything that I do over them, all comunications between either switchs goes down.

It is so curious, cause as I said before using eNSP + GNS3 everything worked well, but in real life is not having the expected behavior.

BTW, doing that over eth-thrunk port, would it be changing the vlan ethertype as well or just qinq?

Cheers

user_2844477 · Created Aug 22, 2019 19:25:23

Have you checked MTU sizes?

Is jumbo frame enabled on Extreme device?

chenhui · Created Aug 23, 2019 01:54:21

Posted by welisson_br at 2019-08-22 12:54 Posted by chenhui at 2019-08-22 12:54hi,did you connect the Extreme X460 to S5720 through interface e ...

hi,
the qinq protocol only modify the outter vlan tag.

please check the picture below:

after the qinq protocol configured as 88a8.

before the qinq protocol configured.

as we can see, the inner vlan tag keeps same no matter if the qinq protocol is configured.

So, you are kindly advised to check if the X460 could process the normal 802.1q VLAN tag.

This article contains more resources

You need to log in to download or view. No account?Register

x

welisson_br · Created Aug 23, 2019 20:15:52

It is quite weird, and so annoying, but we have destroyed and rebuild the aggregation and with a touch of magic everything started working well.

Thx guys

Enterprise

Consumer

Corporate

Carriers

QinQ between Huawei and Extreme Networks

This article contains more resources

Third Party’s Trade Secret