Comparison between flat and layered structure

pintu.sadhu
pintu.sadhu  Platinum  (1)
7 years 10 months ago  View: 777  Reply: 2
1F
Characters 
Flat network
Layered network
Preferred
Network  processing capability
Depends on subscriber number or traffic model
Depends on subscriber number or traffic model
No difference
Number of links
N*(N-1)
K*N+K+K*(K-3)/2 Layered structure
Data configuration and maintenance
Heavy work load; one element revised,all others revised Easy to operate; individual revisal
Layered structure
CAPEX
No investment on tandem layer, but link budget is higher
More CAPEX on tandem network elements, saves link budget
Not clear 
OPEX
Maintenance scale larger;higher OPEX
Simplified structure; lower OPEX
Layered structure
Here,
N is the number of network elements in the network (tandem elements excluded).

K is the number of tandem elements.


Reference: "Evolving core networks from GSM to UMTS R4 Version" by "Ye Ouyang and M. Hosein Fallah"

nsiddique
nsiddique  Silver 
7 years 10 months ago
2F
Good comparison, its nice to see reference. 
mmkabir
mmkabir  Silver 
7 years 10 months ago
3F