Characters | Flat network | Layered network | Preferred | Network processing capability | Depends on subscriber number or traffic model | Depends on subscriber number or traffic model | No difference | Number of links | N*(N-1) | K*N+K+K*(K-3)/2 | Layered structure | Data configuration and maintenance | Heavy work load; one element revised,all others revised | Easy to operate; individual revisal | Layered structure | CAPEX | No investment on tandem layer, but link budget is higher | More CAPEX on tandem network elements, saves link budget | Not clear | OPEX | Maintenance scale larger;higher OPEX | Simplified structure; lower OPEX | Layered structure | Here, N is the number of network elements in the network (tandem elements excluded). K is the number of tandem elements. Reference: "Evolving core networks from GSM to UMTS R4 Version" by "Ye Ouyang and M. Hosein Fallah" |